On Oct. 30, the day Dylan Larkin left the Red Wings, we argued that Detroit could afford to wait for the right trade. The Red Wings were 6-4-3, seventh in the league in five-on-five expected goals share, and their best line did not include him. Since then they are 2-6-0 and have been outscored 26-20. That argument has not held up, and it is worth being clear about why.
Detroit did win 2-0 in Tampa on Sunday, which ended a four-game losing streak. At 8-10-3 it is seventh in the Atlantic with 19 points, nine behind the three teams tied for first. Larkin's suspension runs until at least Dec. 20.
What went wrong?
Two things went wrong at once. The five-on-five play slipped, and the finishing, which we flagged in October, got worse.
Detroit had 55 per cent of the five-on-five expected goals when Larkin left. It is now at 51, 14th. Across all situations it has scored 11.2 fewer goals than its chances were worth, 31st in the league and ahead of only Philadelphia. It is shooting 7.8 per cent at five-on-five, 27th. And it is 3-8 in games decided by one goal.
We wrote then that finishing was Detroit's problem last season too. What we got wrong was assuming the five-on-five play would hold while the finishing caught up. Without its No. 1 centre, it has not.
Where does Larkin's absence show?
Down the middle. The line Detroit now uses most is Viktor Arvidsson, Emmitt Finnie and Alex DeBrincat, with 55 per cent of the expected goals in 117 minutes, and it has been outscored 5-4. The line we pointed to in October, DeBrincat, Finnie and Michael Brandsegg-Nygård, has 63 per cent and is still 8-1, the same goals as three weeks ago, because Detroit has barely kept it together since.
The second line of Lucas Raymond, Andrew Copp and Brandsegg-Nygård has 44 per cent of the chances. Raymond leads the team with 21 points. DeBrincat has seven goals on 72 shots from chances worth 8.9, after scoring 41 last season.
| Detroit, five-on-five, 2026-27 | Minutes | Expected goals share | Goals for-against |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arvidsson, Finnie, DeBrincat | 117 | 55% | 4-5 |
| Raymond, Copp, Brandsegg-Nygård | 105 | 44% | 5-4 |
| DeBrincat, Finnie, Brandsegg-Nygård | 81 | 63% | 8-1 |
| Chiarot and Seider | 220 | 49% | 5-10 |
| Faulk and Wallinder | 161 | 57% | 6-6 |
What about the blue line?
The top pair is losing. Ben Chiarot and Moritz Seider have played 220 five-on-five minutes together, with 49 per cent of the expected goals, and they have been outscored 10-5. Seider has one goal and 13 points after scoring 10 goals and 60 points last season. Justin Faulk and William Wallinder have been the better pair, at 57 per cent.
Is the goaltending part of it?
It depends who is in net. John Gibson has a .862 save percentage in 13 games and has allowed 41 goals on shots worth 33.4, which is 7.6 more than average. Daniil Tarasov is at .931 in nine games and has saved 9.5 goals more than expected, third in the league.
That is a 17-goal swing between two goalies on the same team, and Gibson has played four more games. The penalty kill has not helped either goalie. It is working 71.4 per cent of the time, 26th, and the goaltenders are stopping 80.5 per cent of shots while shorthanded, 23rd.
| Detroit goaltending, 2026-27 | Games | Save % | Goals vs expected |
|---|---|---|---|
| Daniil Tarasov | 9 | .931 | +9.5 |
| John Gibson | 13 | .862 | -7.6 |
The case for waiting, stated fairly
The case for waiting is that Detroit's chances are still close to even, its shooting has been among the worst in the league for reasons that will not all last, and selling Larkin under pressure means taking less than he is worth. Interim general manager Shawn Horcoff has said he will wait as long as it takes, and a team that gives up good players cheaply rarely gets better.
The case against is the calendar. Detroit is nine points out of first and six out of a playoff spot after 21 games, and it has lost ground since the standoff began. The longer it goes, the more teams know Detroit has to move him, and the less the return looks like a No. 1 centre.
Our view is that we underrated how much Larkin was holding together. Detroit should start Tarasov until he gives the job back, and it should make getting a centre the priority in any Larkin deal. Waiting made sense when the Red Wings were winning. It costs them points every week now.
What to watch
Boston visits on Thursday, the Islanders on Sunday and Vancouver next Thursday. Boston has been an ordinary team for a month, which makes it a fair test. Watch who starts in net. Every Detroit number is on the team stats page, and the Atlantic race is on the standings.
