storyNov 17, 2026 · 5 min read

Utah's Crease Is Wasting a Great Team

Utah has the best five-on-five team in the West and has not won in five games. Its goaltenders are 31st in goals saved above expected, and the crease is wasting everything else.

Share
Utah's Crease Is Wasting a Great Team

Utah scored five goals at home on Sunday and still lost, 6-5 in overtime to San Jose. Two nights earlier it lost 1-0 in overtime to St. Louis. The Mammoth have not won in five games, going 0-2-3, and at 10-8-3 they have slipped to fifth in the Central, 11 points behind Minnesota.

That is a strange place for one of the best teams in hockey to be. At five-on-five, Utah has 57 per cent of the expected goals, second in the league behind Carolina and the best mark in the West. It is losing because the puck keeps going in at the wrong end. Utah's goaltenders have allowed 11.7 more goals than the shots against them were worth, 31st of 32 teams. Only Vancouver has been worse.

57.0%
five-on-five expected goals share, 2nd
.890
five-on-five save percentage, 26th
-11.7
goals saved above expected, 31st
0-2-3
last five games

How good is Utah at five-on-five?

Very good in both directions. Utah allows 2.15 expected goals per 60 minutes at five-on-five, the second-fewest in the league, and creates 2.83, fifth. It takes 54 per cent of the shot attempts, fourth. Teams with those numbers are usually near the top of their division.

The scoreboard tells a different story. Utah has been outscored 44-40 at five-on-five. On its chances it should be ahead by about 12, with 48.6 expected goals for and 36.9 against. No team in the league has a bigger gap between how it has played at five-on-five and what the scoreboard shows.

Utah five-on-five goal differential, broken down, 2026-27
Expected goal differential
+11.7
Finishing vs expected
-8.6
Goaltending vs expected
-7.1
Per MoneyPuck. The three bars add up to Utah's actual five-on-five goal differential of minus-four.

Where is it going wrong?

Mostly in the crease. Karel Vejmelka has a .870 save percentage in 15 appearances and has allowed 45 goals on shots worth 38.2, which is 6.8 more than an average goaltender would give up. Sebastian Cossa has been no better in eight games, at .863 and 5.2 goals below expected.

That is a sharp turn for Vejmelka. Last season he played 64 games, stopped .896 and saved 6.9 goals more than expected. He has a full season of being above average behind him, which is why we would not write him off after 15 games. The trouble is that Utah keeps losing games it controls while it waits.

Utah goaltendingGamesSave %Goals vs expected
Vejmelka, 2026-2715.870-6.8
Cossa, 2026-278.863-5.2
Vejmelka, 2025-2664.896+6.9

The shooters have not helped. Utah is scoring on 8.5 per cent of its five-on-five shots, 23rd in the league, and has scored 8.6 fewer five-on-five goals than its chances were worth.

Is the penalty kill still the problem?

It is still bad. On Oct. 28 we wrote that Utah's power play was hiding its penalty kill. Three weeks later the power play is converting 34.7 per cent, second in the league, and the penalty kill is 27th at 70.4 per cent. Utah has allowed 19 goals at four-on-five, and its goaltenders have stopped 77.1 per cent of the shots they have faced there, 30th.

Where we were off was in treating the penalty kill as the main thing dragging Utah down. Since that piece the Mammoth are 2-3-3 and have been outscored 32-24, and the bigger leak has been at five-on-five, where a team allowing chances worth 36.9 goals has given up 44.

Who is being hurt most?

The top pair. Mikhail Sergachev and MacKenzie Weegar have played 250 five-on-five minutes together and have 58 per cent of the expected goals. They have been outscored 14-6. It is hard to play much better than that pair has and lose that badly.

The line of Anders Lee, Barrett Hayton and Kailer Yamamoto has been the best of any regular Utah line, with 72 per cent of the expected goals in 100 minutes, and it is level at 4-4. Clayton Keller leads the team with 27 points, but only five of them are goals.

Utah, five-on-five, 2026-27MinutesExpected goals shareGoals for-against
Sergachev and Weegar25058%6-14
Lee, Hayton, Yamamoto10072%4-4
Cooley, Trocheck, Guenther7252%3-1
Crouse, Schmaltz, Keller6949%2-3

And now the injuries

Utah is getting thin at the worst time. Dylan Guenther is out until at least Dec. 5 and John Marino until at least Dec. 3. Nate Schmidt and Nick Schmaltz are out until at least Nov. 21. Logan Cooley, who leads the team with 11 goals, is day-to-day with an upper-body injury.

The case for patience, stated fairly

The case for patience is that Utah's process is as good as almost anyone's. Its chances for and against are near the top of the league, Vejmelka was above average for all of last season, and save percentage over 21 games swings a lot. If the goaltending gets back to average, this is a team that wins far more often than it loses.

The case against is that Utah is running out of time to find out. It is already 11 points behind Minnesota, three regulars are hurt and its leading goal scorer is banged up. Two goalies struggling at once is also harder to put down to bad luck than one.

Our view is that Utah has a contender's five-on-five game and is not getting a contender's saves. If Vejmelka's next few starts look like his first 15, Utah should be looking for a goaltender, because a team this good at even strength should not be fifth in its division.

What to watch

Vancouver visits on Tuesday, then Colorado on Thursday and Anaheim on Sunday. Vancouver has allowed the most goals in the league, so Utah should control that game. Watch the save percentage, not the shot count. Every Utah number is on the team stats page, and the Central race is on the standings.

Did we get this one right?
Thanks, noted.
Share this story